An independent study by management consulting firm Praxis Global Alliance reveals a stark reality for India’s ₹3.1 lakh crore ($34 billion) general insurance industry: despite celebrating a decade of 11% annual growth, scale has failed to bring structural profitability.
While the sector expanded rapidly—with health and motor insurance making up over 70% of total premiums—the core business of insuring risks remains deeply unprofitable. Indian insurers are currently surviving on investment returns rather than efficient underwriting.
The Metric That Tells the Story: Combined Ratios
The primary gauge of an insurance company’s operational health is its combined ratio—the sum of its underwriting losses, claim payouts, and operational expenses divided by the premiums earned.
-
A ratio below 100% means the company is making an underwriting profit.
-
A ratio above 100% means it is spending more on claims and expenses than it collects in premiums.
Global Benchmarks vs. The Indian Reality
The financial architecture of the Indian general insurance market stands in sharp contrast to mature, Direct-to-Consumer (D2C) global frameworks.
| Metric / Attribute | Top Indian General Insurers | Global D2C Counterparts | Economic Impact |
| Combined Ratio | 110% – 113% | 84% – 89% | Indian players lose ₹10–13 on every ₹100 of premium collected. |
| Core Underwriting Profit | -13% Net Written Premium | Highly Profitable | Local losses must be fully subsidized by capital gains. |
| Primary Profit Driver | Investment Income (~21%) | Sound Underwriting Discipline | India’s model relies entirely on floating funds in the stock/bond markets. |
The Broken Promise: A Survey of 1,203 Consumers
A key component of the Praxis report—a consumer survey tracking 1,203 motor and health insurance customers across India—shatters the argument that high intermediary commissions are justified by superior customer service. Instead, the study reveals a massive execution gap between what traditional agents promise and what policyholders experience during a crisis.
The Disappearing Agent: The survey highlighted that independent intermediaries were frequently cited as completely unavailable or unreachable at the critical claims stage—the exact moment when customers required their personalized support the most.
The Structural Pivot Ahead
Because of these persistent operational challenges, 52% of motor customers and 54% of health customers explicitly stated they would immediately switch to buying direct from an insurer if service quality and claim handholding could be structurally guaranteed.
Madhur Singhal, Managing Partner at Praxis Global Alliance, notes that simply shifting toward global underwriting discipline without changing premium pricing volumes would expand the industry’s profit pool by 2.8 times and more than double its Return on Equity (RoE).
Regulators and industry headers believe a combination of upcoming frameworks—including increased commission transparency, the government-backed Bima Sugam digital marketplace, the adoption of Ind AS 117 accounting systems, and tighter risk-based capital mandates—will eventually force Indian insurers to prioritize customer retention and direct relationship ownership over third-party broker dependencies.
